Taking a Second Look at an Underqualified Candidate

You receive so many resumes you’re always looking at reasons to rule someone out. But what if you should be ruling a candidate in? Taking a second look at a candidate you determined was underqualified may be exactly what your department needs. Hiring for experience isn’t always the most important thing. Employers who hire for potential often have higher retention rates. Here are a few things to look at when making your next hiring decision.  

Attitude and Aptitude  

Not every candidate will match up exactly to your expectations. But when you review their potential, consider the characteristics that can match your company culture. Even candidates with fewer years of experience can have all the right soft-skills necessary to learn and excel at the job. Look at every factor, not just experience. Look at their attitude, aptitude, interest, and personality.  

Long Term Goals 

Since you can’t evaluate their experience in identical roles, you can look at patterns of behavior in previous jobs. For example, were they often given additional responsibilities? Did their employers recognize them for hard work? Talk to the candidate about what they see for their future career. You can learn a lot about their motivation and determine if that’s a match for your team.  

Fill a Hole 

Business success is a team sport. It never lies on just one person’s shoulder. That means you have to architect your dream team to drive innovation. Candidates who are excited about their next opportunity will have the excitement level to help the team improve and thrive. Look for candidates with the potential to fill an important role in your department.  

Evaluate Performance  

Once you do hire an underqualified candidate, you need to focus on their onboarding experience and job training. They may take a little longer to get up to speed, but if they have potential they will do well. Rather than dumping them in a training program, consider matching them with a mentor. This person will be their go-to for questions and learning experiences. But be sure to provide feedback regularly, both constructive suggestions for improvement and praise for a job well done.  

Could hiring for potential help your business succeed? 

Contact Nextaff to see how we can help today.  

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on
our website, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from.

Meet Shane...

Shane’s journey with Nextaff began in 2019, when he established a successful franchise in the Kansas City metro area. His experience as a Nextaff franchise owner provides prospective buyers with a completely transparent view of the Nextaff Franchise Opportunity. Prior to his time at Nextaff, Shane led large sales teams in the Financial Services and Medical Device industries, further developing his expertise in leadership and business management.

Do you play sports?

Basketball! I was fortunate enough to play college basketball all 4 years and in 2013 we won the NCAA DII National Championship.

What do you love most about your current role?

Getting to know prospective franchise buyers. I love hearing about their goals and dreams they want to achieve through entrepreneurship.

What is your favorite color?

Orange! Yes, it is one of Nextaff’s main colors but it was my favorite before coming to Nextaff. In the franchising world, I’m known as “Orange pants guy”.

Meet Cary...

When it comes to operating a staffing firm, Cary has worn every hat.  From recruiting, to sales, to management, to ownership, he has been involved in every aspect of running a successful staffing business.  He has successfully led three separate companies to the Inc. 500 and Inc. 5000 lists, which puts him in an elite class of staffing entrepreneurship.  Combining that experience with a strong passion for entrepreneurs makes Cary an ideal leader for driving the Nextaff vision. 

Describe yourself in three words.

Loyal, Driven, Creative

Is there a mantra or affirmation you live by?

Do what you said you were going to do.

Do you have a celebrity doppelganger?

Back in the day, it was John Cusak.  “I want my two dollars!”